How to Live
Subscribe
Cover photo

Do You Constantly Scan Your Relationships for Emotional Threats? It's Called Hypervigilance and it's Exhausting.

How to reign in this prehistoric reflex.

Amanda Stern

16 Mar
3
31

If you missed last week's post about my favorite anxiety resources, you can read it here: My Favorite Anxiety Resources for People of All Ages. And if you're new here, and want to join our thriving community, please Subscribe. The newsletter is free.

The How to Live BOOKSHOP is now open!

I spent my entire childhood orbiting my mother on a hypervigilant 24-hour watch, making sure she wouldn’t disappear into thin air, accidentally cross the street on red and get hit by a car, or simply forget she had a family and move to another country while we were sleeping. This is why I slept in her bedroom for years—well past an appropriate age— jarred awake by the slightest rustle of a bedsheet. In the language of attachment theory—which states the care given to babies by their primary caregiver influences the way they’ll attach in their relationships as adults—I am anxiously attached.

The circumstances into which we are born and the conditions in which we are raised creates the blueprint for all future interactions and patterns of engagement and connection. Not long after I was born, my parents separated and then divorced. Perhaps that’s why connection with people I love is intertwined with the threat of imminent loss. Who knows? Whatever the case, something triggered my genetic predisposition for anxiety, and it flourished under the guidance of hypervigilance.

Hypervigilance itself is not a mental health condition. Rather, it’s a symptom associated with a variety of mental health disorders, including PTSD, panic disorder, generalized anxiety disorder, and mood disorders. To be hypervigilant means to be on high-alert all the time, and prone to overreaction. It is being primed for war, ready at a moment’s notice to run or hide, even when you're just sitting at dinner with friends and loved ones.

When anxious people feel that their attachments are threatened, they can grow hypervigilant to all their attachments. As children, survival depends upon the caretaker’s survival, and an anxious baby will be on constant alert for confirmation that their caretaker is alive. I was always scanning my environment for threats that might separate me from my mother, thinking that my hypervigilance, and its accompanying worry, would prevent her death, or my own, from whatever trauma might tear us apart. As I grew and changed, this aspect of me remained the same; it simply attached and organized itself around different relationships.

Hypervigilance of this sort is a survival instinct, and to live inside of it is to remain emotionally dysregulated. To live in modern society is to exist in a constant state of bombardment. We’re inundated by information, stimulus, and the mistaken belief that filling time is more important than experiencing it. Because of the demands of contemporary life, we are unable to truly digest a response in full, or move through a complete experience. Many of us exist in a half-digested life. This keeps us stuck in an unfinished loop, and it’s there, in the interruption, the halfway point, that hypervigilance lives. Without a way to move through this heightened state of arousal by self-regulating, we are often left to reach for something to numb or manage our emotions—including self-medicating, self-harm, or disordered eating.

When hypervigilant children grow up and edge out into the world, they tend to scan their environment for things that signal whether or not they are safe. In all relationships, but especially romantic ones, they are highly attuned to emotional and physical absences, anything that signals disconnection or feels dangerous, like neglect or exclusion; any small shifts that telegraph such a change.

These slights feel threatening, and the hypervigilant scanner, upon sensing they are being neglected or excluded (or whichever emotional signal to which they're most sensitive) feel like they need to protect themselves at whatever cost. They either cling to the person they feel is disconnecting, or they flee. The hypervigilant is overly aware of the body language, actions, and behaviors of their loved ones. They can analyze things into oblivion, turning something innocuous into something dangerous. We are so aware of being abandoned or hurt that we believe scanning for hurts, and analyzing said hurts, will protect us from being hurt.

People with trauma and mental health issues who have had to battle their way through life, are highly intuitive, sensitive, and exquisitely empathetic. This makes being hypervigilant even more exhausting. Like Feist sang, “I [We] feel it all.”

Why do some people operate in a state of hypervigilance, while others operate at the other extreme—excessive self-reliance and independence? There are many ways to answer this, it just depends on which lens you choose to use. The alertness of the hypervigilant is evolutionary.

We know that adverse childhood experiences can lead to hypervigilance (among many other symptoms) and that hypervigilance is a trauma response, but let’s go farther back and look at the roots of the hypervigilant response.

As hirsute prehistoric creatures, we ran in small packs to forage for mushrooms, seeds and other food, and we were always on guard. While we were out looking for food, so were giant ground sloths, mastodons, sabertooth cats, dire wolves and bears—and we were their food. Our survival instinct was highly attuned, and the quietest rustle of a leaf signaled a threat. Upon receiving that signal, our bodies released hormones triggering a physical change, and priming us to fight, or flee.

Heritage Images / Getty

Here’s what that chain of command looks like in the brain: When someone experiences a stressful event, it activates the amygdala, which is responsible for our emotions and our memories. We have two amygdalae on either side of our brain, and while we often refer to it as our "fear center" its job is to detect the emotional resonance of all stimuli, and all strong emotion: is it joyful, fearful, stressful, enthralling? It is also the seat of the fight or flight response. When the amygdala receives a trigger for fear, it sends a distress signal to the hypothalamus, in the command center. The hypothalamus yells for the sympathetic nervous system to step on the gas, which it does, triggering the fight-or-flight response.

This automatic stress response and the corresponding physiological changes, kept us (and still keeps us) alive, and therefore served us well, but now millions of years later, our brains haven’t evolved as quickly as the world around us, and we are still operating as though we are prey. The fight-or-flight response is part of a primitive and ancient system that is still living in prehistoric times. Our brains don't know the difference between a physical threat caused by a charging Mastadon or the emotional threat of a possible relationship-ending fight with our partner. This is why when we worry, feel stress, or fear, our bodies can react as though we’re in physical danger, and flood us with adrenaline and cortisol.

Getty Images

Yet, in situations without a clear and present danger, the adrenaline and cortisol of the fight or flight response have nowhere to turn but into anxiety.

To be constantly on guard is to be operating purely on survival instinct, and it is exhausting—for everyone. As an adult, the hypervigilantes often behave like detectives in their romantic relationships, looking for clues to ensure that no one has suddenly changed their minds about us, or is cheating. If we find ourselves excessively worrying over the dynamics of our relationship, obsessing over every behavioral cue, and analyzing body language that might foretell impending disconnection, we are being hypervigilant in our relationships.

When we are in a truly hypervigilant state, we are trapped inside a feeling of chronic dread. This is an unbearable experience that often finds us short of breath, and feeling extremely vulnerable. Dread and terror feel very similar, and when we are overcome by these feelings, it's very difficult, if not impossible, to form close relationships with others. Those who live with hypervigilance tend to isolate rather than experience the terror of the dread.

When I am in a relationship, and something happens that triggers that horrifying dread, I assume the message it's sending me is to run from the relationship. This, of course, elicits even more dread and suddenly I’m paralyzed. But I learned recently that we often (and almost always) misunderstand what our dread is trying to tell us. Usually, it’s not telling us we need to leave; it’s telling us that something is happening in our relationship that we don't like, and we need to communicate.

For those who suffer from anxiety, having to communicate is an extremely anxiety-producing prospect, but compared to having to leave a relationship, it’s a lot easier, and doable. Learning how to identify what our dread is trying to tell us can help tame our hypervigilance, and learning how to communicate what the dread is trying to tell us will help our relationships.

Dread is often a symptom of panic disorder. It also shows up in people suffering from depression and anxiety, and is very prevalent in those experiencing symptoms of PTSD. When you feel it, it’s a good idea to breathe through it, either with someone you trust, or on your own. I like the 4-7-8 breathing method for dread.

Often, we can identify what the dread is trying to tell us because it tends to flare immediately, telling us what it doesn’t like. Your partner did something and the dread activated. What did your partner do? Look at what led up to the feelings of dread to put your finger on what caused it.

Original art for How to Live by Edwina White

HOW TO DEAL WITH IT

Hypervigilance and the corresponding dread that comes with it is an unconscious process, and like all unconscious processes, it takes conscious effort to dismantle it.

My first line of defense may not be appealing to many, but it helps me if I can trace the feeling back to the trigger so that I can understand why I am in the hypervigilant state I’m in, or why I’m suddenly filled with dread. Once I can find the root cause I can figure out what's really bothering me and then label the trigger “Not scary” and mentally file it away.

But there are other effective ways to deal with chronic hypervigilance. One way is through EMDR (eye movement desensitization and reprocessing) therapy. This technique allows your brain to introduce and integrate traumatic memories so that they get properly processed and are no longer as distressful.

Neurofeedback Therapy teaches you how to relax your brain and nervous system. Over time, this method teaches your brain to have different responses to overwhelming things and to heal.

Meditation or deep breathing, is also really helpful at calming down your sympathetic nervous system. Because hypervigilance keeps us in a consistent state of high alert, deep, long breathing signals to our parasympathetic system (our in-house nurse) that we’re ready to be calm. My favorite meditations can be found here.

Somatic Experiencing Therapy and Internal Family Systems (often called "Parts Therapy") are both excellent modalities for hypervigilance. Somatic Experiencing can help you in the moments of hypervigilance, when you are overcome by the sense that your dread is going to kill you. One thing you learn in these therapies is that we are every age we've ever been, and when we've experienced trauma as a young person, we become stuck inside the trauma at the age it happened, and so our present reaction to an emotional experience is usually a past trauma response that we mistake for our feelings in the present.

One method is to recognize that the part of you who is responding to the threat, is not the you currently, but the you of the past. The version of you at age 3, 6, or 9 who first felt the trauma that led to the hypervigilance and dread but who lacks the ability to articulate what she feels, knowing only that it feels like her existence is at stake. That’s the feeling that remains, and if we can learn to identify and recognize that the person who has shown up to declare that we feel dread is a younger version of us, reporting on the same feeling, but from a totally different experience, we can start to distinguish between what feels true and what is actually happening.

The experience of feeling disconnected is frightening, and the act of being hypervigilant is a maladaptive way of guarding against our fear of separation. Recognizing that hypervigilance is a symptom of feeling emotionally dysregulated is a great starting point. It’s not who we are, it’s simply an ancient response doing what it was programmed to do, and until we explain to our hypervigilance that it’s time here has run its course, and it’s time to find a new line of work, it will continue. It's hard work, but worth it. It's always always worth it.

And you? Are you a scanner? And do you find yourself scanning most in your romantic relationships, or elsewhere?

Let me know in the comments!

Thank you for reading.

Until next week, I am…

Amanda

Amanda

If "How to Live" offers you something of value, please share with others!

🆓 Subscribe HERE. It's FREE!

👯‍♀️ Tell a friend! Forward or share the link!

💃🏼 Share on Twitter, Facebook, WhatsApp, LinkedIn or via email.

💬 Join the Discussion to meet us in the comments!

Want to go deeper? Check the archive.

The best way to support my work is to buy my book Little Panic: Dispatches from an Anxious Life or hire me to speak.

Subscribe to How to Live
By subscribing, you agree to share your email address with Amanda Stern to receive their original content, including promotions. Unsubscribe at any time. Meta will also use your information subject to the Bulletin Terms and Policies
3
31

More from How to Live
See all

You Asked Me ANYTHING About Anxiety And I Answered!

If you've just landed here for the first time, welcome!
25 May

Rescuing Others From Facing Personal Hardship Isn't Loving; It's Codependency. PART TWO

"How to Live" is a free weekly newsletter highlighting material from the worlds of psychology and mental health written by a person just trying to figure out how to live. Subscribe! It's free.
18 May
8
17

Are You Trapped Inside The “Tyranny of the Shoulds”? You Might be Suffering from Codependency.

On Karen Horney, Neurotic Needs and Relationship Addiction.
11 May
22
8
Comments
Log in with Facebook to comment

31 comments

  • Virgie Tovar
    Writes Body Positive University
    As a hypervigilante myself, I loved learning that part of the belief is that worry can prevent physical harm - ugh. Clearly not true and yet such a powerful belief.
    • 10 w
    • Author
      Amanda Stern
      Yeah, a big aspect of anxiety is the mistaken belief that worrying keeps you and/or others safe. Existing is so hard!!
      3
      • 10 w
    View 2 more replies
  • Teresa N. Brown
    This was such an eye opener for me. I have this response any time I start talking to a guy. I overthink, I get this feeling of dread and anxiety. If it doesn't work out or even look like it's not going to work out, these feelings overwhelm me. …
    See more
    • 10 w
    • Author
      Amanda Stern
      That's a lot to deal with. Have you ever tried EMDR? It's amazing. I highly recommend looking into it, and/or reading Waking the TIger by Peter Levine. https://amzn.to/3iiq6wQ
      Waking the Tiger: Healing Trauma
      AMAZON.COM
      Waking the Tiger: Healing Trauma
      Waking the Tiger: Healing Trauma
      • 10 w
    View 1 more reply
  • Jessica Booth
    “When I am in a relationship, and something happens that triggers that horrifying dread, I assume the message it's sending me is to run from the relationship. This, of course, elicits even more dread and suddenly I’m paralyzed.” …
    I could never have …
    See more
    • 10 w
    • Author
      Amanda Stern
      Yes, dread of this type often indicates trauma. Somatic Experiencing (which I'm writing about now) helped me IMMENSELY while I was going through this. It's so so so hard to live that way, and it's so so so so hard to work to change it. I'm so happy you…
      See more
      • 10 w
  • Curtis Anne Moore
    Great article as always!!
    So, my wife is a hypervigilante, but I am not. Her childhood was fraught with intermittent abuse by a sperm donor while mine was safe and secure except for the presence of alcohol (lucky for me, all my parents did was emotion…
    See more
    • 10 w
    • Author
      Amanda Stern
      Sounds like despite it being hard and tiring, you two have figured out a way to manage it. (I LOL'd at your "lucky for me, all my parents did was emotionally neglect me vs abuse me") I'm writing about childhood neglect soon...so stay tuned. And yes, we…
      See more
      • 10 w
    View 1 more reply
  • Kelley Brodbeck
    Really enjoyed this article. I am hyper vigilant due to a medical trauma I experienced and love to find new resources! Thank you! It’s good to know we are not alone in our struggle.
    • 10 w
    • Author
      Amanda Stern
      So happy you found your way here! I will be writing more dedicated trauma pieces, so stay tuned. That said, I do think everything I write about has its roots in trauma to some extent. I don't think it's possible to live this life without incurring trau…
      See more
      • 10 w
  • Allie Allison Mann
    I had a counselor tell me once that my hyper-vigilance makes me an excellent perciever but a very poor interpreter. That slight shift in energy isn’t even about me. 🤦🏼‍♀️ And yes, it’s been exhausting for me and anyone around me. I’m learning how to bi…
    See more
    • 10 w
    • Author
      Amanda Stern
      So happy you found your way here. Welcome! And what a super smart way to frame this: perceiver vs interpreter. That is so right on. I love it.
      • 10 w
  • Kathy Preis Pompe
    Wow! I really see myself in this article!! I am the one who walks away without looking back. Being alone is easier than dealing with the anxiety of trying to constantly "save" a relationship. Upon looking back I see I was the one causing the discomf…
    See more
    • 10 w
    • Author
      Amanda Stern
      I hear you, Kathy. It's SO hard. But there really is hope and if I can face the anxiety I've had since I was an infant, anyone can. I truly believe that.
      • 10 w
  • Jessica H Day
    PSYCHED I found you (thx Debbie Reber)- I needed that. I will get your book asap. Your article so beautifully covers all the pieces- so well done-sheesh. Im in it thick right now and working with Irene Lyons (Somatic Experiencing). Holy effing triggers…
    See more
    • 7 w
    • Author
      Amanda Stern
      Thank you Jess (and Debbie Reber!!) I am working on a piece about Somatic Experiencing right now. Here's the thing--there's not one modality that is THE ONE. I truly believe it's an integrative approach that helps most, and it sounds like you're doing …
      See more
      • 7 w
    View 1 more reply
  • Danielle Weinzetl
    I never knew that who I am has a name , hypervigilant . Like when I think back to my child hood I can’t think of what would of caused me to become this person that is this way.
    • 10 w
    • Author
      Amanda Stern
      I think it's really difficult, if not impossible, to put your finger on why because we can't remember and don't have reliable narrators for our earliest years. Also, so much is absorbed emotionally and somatically when we're so little, it would be toug…
      See more
      • 10 w
    View 4 more replies
  • Lori Countey
    great article!!!!
    • 10 w
    • Author
      Amanda Stern
      Thank you, Lori!
      • 10 w
View 1 more comment
Share quoteSelect how you’d like to share below
Share on Facebook
Share to Twitter
Send in WhatsApp
Share on LinkedIn
Privacy  ·  Terms  ·  Cookies
© Meta 2022
Discover fresh voices. Tune into new conversations. Browse all publications